Beginning the complaint with a bang - the case synopsis

We are changing the way we read.  Short has not just become better.  It has become essential in the quest to capture the attention of our audience.

Pedantic legal writing is no longer highly valued by judges.   With crushing case loads, our Honors need us to get right to the point.  They impose page limits on us.  And even then, will sometimes admit they haven't read our pleadings.

Read More
The almost tantrum: a tale of typical trial lawyer self control

It's a drizzly Sunday.  Have popped into the office to work on a settlement letter.  Nala is chewing on her antler.  Am eating my favorite pastry from Macrina bakery - the orange pinwheel.  Superb as usual.

Am working on the letter.  But also engaging in typical bounce around behavior.  Read incoming email from co-counsel on a different case. Defense attorney wants a continuance on a summary judgment motion.  This is the fifth motion in a string of motions.  Maybe it's the fourth.  Or the sixth.  Have lost count.

Read More
The non-visitor: a story about never saying you're sorry.

Walk up to door one.  Open and walk through.  Door two.  Push button.  It clicks.  Enter.  Write name and time on log at front desk.  Write name on tag and stick on shirt.  Cindy arrives and says hello.  Follow her down the linoleum covered hall.  Past the man in a wheelchair.  An open door reveals a woman in bed watching tv.  A hunched over man looks at me from another open door.   His leg is bandaged.   Walk towards the eating area where several others are congregated.  Mostly in wheelchairs.  Chatting.  Average age probably middle 70s.  Or older.

Read More
Part 3: Depositions of treating providers in a medical negligence case resulting in bilateral leg amputations.

One of the hospital’s defenses was that it was a small community hospital.  It did not have all the fancy equipment of a major urban hospital.   The problem with this defense was that the hospital didn’t need an expensive machine to make the correct diagnosis.  All it needed, was for someone to: a) notice the red flags; and b) pull a hand held doppler unit out of a cupboard.

Read More
Part 1: Depositions of treating providers in a bilateral leg amputation medical negligence case

Am at a hospital.  Sitting on one side of a long table in a cafeteria.    With me is my partner Paul Whelan and paralegal Cheryl Baldwin.  Paul  has been handling medical negligence cases since I was in grade school.  He is my Yoda.  Cheryl screened this case and knows everything that I need to know.   Between the two of them, I'm covered.

Read More
Some defense lawyers can't be friends too...

Last week something unpleasant happened.

I lost a friend.  Not a great one.  But a friend nonetheless.

I met him when he was still a law student and was one of his mentors.  He clerked for our firm.   Then a bit later he worked with us for a year.  He stayed in our building after that, working for another lawyer who was renting an office from us.  We kept in touch.   His boss moved his office.  And we wished them well.  A bit later,  I heard  he had quit and decided to take a job with a defense firm.  No shame in that.  You gotta do what you gotta do.

Read More
Is this the biggest bozo move ever by a defense medical examiner

Before this happened, the dumbest thing I ever witnessed in a defense medical exam, was one of the doctors falling asleep.

It was a two doctor panel exam.  While the orthopedist was taking a history, the neurologist was reading a political thriller.  I thought that was bad enough until midway through.  His head was nodding and then jerking forward.  Like a puppet on a string held by Mr. Sandman.  Until he gave in.  Chin coming to rest on his chest.  At least he didn't snore.

Read More
Reminder or threat: an insurance company's intimidation tactics

Insurance companies cite the "duty to cooperate clause" when they are forcing the person they insure, to provide information.  If you don't give them the information they ask for, then they will maintain that the entire policy is void and you are not entitled to make any claim.   In this case, I'm the one who said no on behalf of my client their insurer - and in return they quoted the clause.

Here is what happened.

Read More
Karen Koehlerinsurance
Damages Opening Statement: catastrophic brain injury case

Both sides used extensive demonstrative exhibits during opening.  Basically we agreed that I could use what I wanted so long as they could use what they wanted.

The transcript is not very accurate (understatement).  The courtroom was video recorded.  If we wanted a quick transcript, at the end of the day  the bailiff would copy the recordings and provided them to a court reporter. The reporter would then transcribe from the videos with only moderate success.

Read More